Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

A Father Sends his Son with Autism to School Wearing 'A Wire' and exposes abuse -

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    A Father Sends his Son with Autism to School Wearing 'A Wire' and exposes abuse -

    Today's Huffington Post reported on a youtube video which has gone viral over the last 12 hours:





    When Stuart Chaifetz sent his 10-year-old son to New Jersey's Horace Mann Elementary School wearing a hidden audio recorder, he couldn't have predicted what he would uncover.
    The move came in reaction to accusations from the school that his son Akian was having "violent outbursts," including hitting his teacher and teacher's aide -- claims that Chaifetz claims are against his son's "sweet and non-violent" nature.
    Akian, who has Autism, returned with a tape containing hours of apparent verbal and emotional abuse from his classroom aide and teacher -- whom Chaifetz identifies as "Jodi" and "Kelly" -- a recording which his father later published on YouTube.
    The Feb. 17 recording started with Akian's aide and the teacher, whom Collingswood Patch provides evidence may be Jodi Sgouros and Kelly Altenburg, respectively, based on a previously published online staff directory.
    The two engage in inappropriate conversations, like joking about their alcohol abuse and sex lives in front of their students -- all of whom have behavioral conditions and, according to Chaifetz, communication difficulties that prevent them from relaying the conversations to their parents.
    At the time of writing this, the facebook link to the story has 109 'likes' and 49 comments. Every single comment was in favour of the father's actions.

    Parents' gut feelings about something wrong in their child's life are very often borne out after all the evidence is in. Clearly, it is much more difficult to gather information from a child who is non-speaking or an elderly person with dementia. But for people who know and love someone with these handicaps, listening and watching closely offer up clues to what may be awry in caregiving relationships.

    The biggest flag in this story and others I have heard anecdotally in the parent community is a school or other institution that does not welcome unplanned visits from parents. Open lines of communication and complete transparency should be absolute givens where the care of vulnerable people is concerned.

    In 1995, we lived in London and after two years of intensive conductive education, we were looking for another school for Nicholas. Carole Greenaway was our educational psychologist and I remember one day visiting a special school with Carole. We were given a tour of Grove Park and I recall asking about visiting Nick's classroom and about opportunities to volunteer at the school. On both counts, I was told that parents were unwelcome, but could be accommodated with plenty of prior notice.

    Walking back to the car in the parking lot, Carole and I looked at each other and we both made a gesture of thumbs down. Shaking our heads, we chatted about what bad things could happen to vulnerable children behind closed doors.

    Today, I asked myself whether I would want CCTV surveillance in Nicholas' room. It didn't take me long to decide that no, we don't need it and we wouldn't want it. I drop in to visit Nick almost every day. If I don't visit, I call and Nicholas tells me everything, even though his speech is extremely limited. My gut tells me that Nick's care is fantastic and every day, I feel grateful.

    But I do not judge people who do want surveillance cameras for their vulnerable loved ones who live in institutional settings. My next post will be about one woman who tried and failed to get the right to have cameras installed in Ontario nursing homes.

    This is from my blog, for live links and a photo of Aiken Chaifetz, go to Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...
    I would LOVE to know what others think about this story and hear about your own experiences with abuse at school and how you monitor your kids.
    Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
    Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com


    #2
    those women should be ashamed. maybe even fired. I think the dad's surveillance was the right thing to do.

    Comment


      #3
      I agree with his actions as well. I was shocked and horrified when I listened to the tape. It was so awful.
      Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
      Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

      Comment


        #4
        ((((((Donna))))))

        Everyone should read the entire article, which describes the verbal abuse perpetrated by the teacher and the aide on the boy and other students. Cruel, despicable, harmful bullying. Imagine enduring that day after day, with no choice to get away from it. Imprisoned in a classroom with vicious adults harassing and tormenting you continuously. And rendered unable to explain it to your parent or anyone who might be able to rescue you.

        The aide was fired, but the teacher was reassigned to another classroom. Typical. The Teachers Union is mighty powerful.

        That teacher should be fired, her credential permanently revoked, along with her pension, and she should be barred from stepping into any classroom anywhere.

        Due process exists for this situation, if the father wants to file for a Fair Hearing with the State, and file a civil rights complaint on behalf of his son. The Office of Civil Rights used to love these kinds of cases, and they investigated under every rock. Schools used to fear them.

        Whether all parents are aware of their rights and due process is another question. Unless a state and or community provides watchdog and advocacy agencies, parents are on their own with due process. And the school districts aren't about to tell you your rights.

        If I were the parent in this situation, I would follow due process no matter how long it took, and when that was resolved, I would hire a private attorney and sue the school district for child abuse. And I'd be sure to invite the media to the courtroom.

        If we, as parents, don't shine a glaring light on the horrendous state of our educational system, and the multitude of abuses going on inside our school buildings, nothing will ever change.

        I'm positive that this child isn't the only child in the U.S. or anywhere in the world to be the victim of teacher abuse. Morever, this child wasn't the only child in that classroom being abused by the teacher and aide. They were all victims.

        A few months ago, an elementary school in Los Angeles was closed, and all of the teachers were transferred to another school, while a new batch of teachers were brought into the closed school. The reason: a teacher's sexual perversion and abuse with his students as victims happening right there in the classroom. And then a second teacher at that school was arrested for the same kind of crime. This school serves a lower income, primarily immigrant community ~ a different kind of vulnerable population.

        Recently in my city, an elementary school teacher was placed on administrative leave, while he was being investigated by the police for "inappropriate material" on his school computer. (Fill in the blanks)

        And this kind of garbage is happening all over the U.S.

        Any school, which doesn't allow parent drop-in visits needs to be called out by all parents of students in that school. We need Parent Unions now to combat the power of the Teacher Unions and the lack of supervision by school districts to ensure that they meet the letter of every law.

        The schools/districts are counting on the fact that most parents are working constantly and unable to make surprise visits. They are relieved that parents are too busy and overwhelmed to even question whether their children are being abused at school. School is the place, where most parents expect their children to be safe and cared for properly. It's the last place they would suspect foul play by those entrusted with their children for hours a day 5 days a week.

        That is all the more reason to be proactive and attune to our children, so we can see red flags.

        I applaud this dad for sleuthing on behalf of his son, and I think he should take it further legally. Although I haven't had a chance to listen to the tape, I don't have to hear it to know that this boy and his classmates were being abused daily.

        As a former teacher, I'm appalled at what has happened to this once noble profession. I'm absolutely disgusted that parents have to worry now whether their children are safe with their teachers. As a parent, this infuriates me.

        Love & Light,

        Rose
        Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

        Comment


          #5
          Wonderful, wonderful post, Rose. I listened to the tape and it is sickening. I saw another blog on the same topic by another Mum - Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register.... Rose, if this happened to my child, I would go absolutely ballistic and I would definitely take my child out (obviously) and probably go to the press if the teachers were not removed immediately. I think what happened at this man's school reflects a general de-valueing of children and people with disabilities, especially cognitive disabilities. Many have made the point that this type of behaviour would never happen in a class of able-bodied children. It's so awful - the tape is worse than you can imagine. I'm a teacher in my old life, too.
          Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
          Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

          Comment


            #6
            I agree with Rose! I actually live in wisconsin, where our Govenor took a lot of power away from the teacher's unions...not sure if y'all have heard anything about all that in the news where you are. I was glad about it. There were a lot of good changes made in our district. The ones that benefit my family the most was the schedule changes (no more 'late start days' every month or weird half days off and such), before the changes I felt my kids rarely had a week where they were in school 5 days in a row. This yr has been great. But aside from all that, I am glad that we are lucky enough to have been able to choose the district we are in. We were in a, well, sh*tty district and when Caitlin was about to turn 3 and enter early childhood at school....we put our house up for sale and moved into a better district (the one we are still in now). I had asked all her birth to 3 therapists which ones were good or not. I am lucky Caitlin has had great teachers and aides, and I am always welcomed when I drop in the class. I bring her to school 2 days a week (when we have early am appts) and 2 of my other kids are in the same school building (they go to the 'charter school' but it's in the same building as the regular elementary so they do see each other often). My boys are also in the 'circle of friends' program where they actually get to go into Caitlin's class and work with her & her classmates for special things....for building friendships and understanding with the regular kids & CD kids. They enjoy it and I like that I know she is getting good care. I feel so bad when I read about things like this article going on or how some online friends can't send their kids to school as they can't trust the care their child gets there. I can't imagine! Though...there are bad regular class teachers too...we had our first experience with that this year. I actually didn't really know how to handle it and did not post anything about it at all on fb since I have so many teacher/aide friends on there. My 6 yr old first grader had a teacher that seemed to just not like him (or me) from day 1. The final straw was when another boy talked my Tyler into pretending to smoke with a woodchip from the playground. Dumb, yes. Apparently they were putting the woodchips in their mouth and pretending to be smoking (and we don't do that so I have no idea how that even sounded cool to him). A playground lady caught them and told the teacher who then talked to the boys and said to Tyler that "if he liked woodchips so much that he should eat a whole tray of them for lunch". The whole thing was just so weird and apparently she yelled this at him because the next day I got an email from her apologising to me & Brian that she overreacted! There were other weird incidents before this one so I ended up scheduling a mtg with the principal and we had Tyler switched to the other first grade teacher. We were originally going to switch him back to the regular elementary school but decided to not give up on the charter before trying the other teacher and seeing if it was just a personality conflict. He is doing great now with the other teacher! I know he can be difficult, I think since he is the middle child, he sometimes feel shorted on attention. Obviously with 4 kids and with caitlin requiring a lot more than others he really could be justified in feeling that way. It was hard to do something though as I didn't want to rock the boat at school and start trouble. I hate confrontation! I am glad I did it though and that I handled it in a classy way...this is the first time I have written anything about it online. (there is more unsaid about it but you get the idea from what I did put here). I am just glad he could tell us stuff...and I think these parents of special needs kids who use surveillance are entirely justified. How else can they know what goes on?? I think surveillance is a good thing in situations like this. For instance, when I joined the gym I go to, it was all about getting a break from Logan (my most challenging child-Caitlin is easy, Logan is the most work for me...then & now!)...he was 2 then and could talk a little. But my gym's playcare has cameras that broadcast to a tv in the lobby/lounge area of the gym so parents can peek at them if they want. (the playcare is in a separate building next to the gym). I like the extra layer of transparency....just like I like that I can drop into Caitlin's school and peek in anytime and feel welcomed. I sure would not feel that my kids were as safe without having those options available to me. Time to end my rambling! :)

            Lisa O.
            sigpicLisa O: mom to Caitlin (14-CP, VA shunt, seizures), Brandon (12), Tyler (10), Logan (7)...my babies are all getting so old!!

            Comment


              #7
              Thanks for sharing that, Lisa. I actually remember you saying that you worried that Logan's teacher had a personality conflict with him and you - at least I'm pretty sure I recall that! I also wrote a short piece about surveillance cameras in nursing homes because bad stuff happened to a friend and it ended up on the news - I didn't repost here because it's an eldercare issue, but as we're talking surveillance cameras, here it is: (and the link to the news item is: Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...


              One of my mother-in-law's best friends was a woman called Jean Holden, or "Mrs. Holden", as we always knew her. Mrs. Holden was a smiley woman with a sing-song laugh and perfect posture. Mr. Holden, Alec, was always by her side until he passed away, leaving Jean to live out her old age without her beloved spouse to lean on. The Holdens were natives of Montreal whose children grew up with my husband and his siblings. The two families were very close.

              I knew that the Holdens had a daughter called Janet, but I had never met her. I knew that Mrs. Holden had tried to live out her old age in Montreal, because for a time she lived in the same seniors residence as my mother. But residents at my Mum's home must be fully independent and Mrs. Holden's health took a turn for the worse. So, she moved to London, Ontario to be closer to her daughter Janet.

              Occasionally, I receive messages via my website from readers of my book. A few months ago, I received a message from Janet Holden Brumell, Jean's daughter, and we began a correspondence about Jean's tribulations at the end of her life at a nursing home in London. Jean had fallen a number of times, a fact denied by administrative at the home and that's when Janet decided to take action. She placed a hidden camera in her mother's room and began to watch the footage which proved to be alarming.

              CTV did a story on Mrs. Holden and Janet's struggle to have closed circuit cameras in Ontario Long Term Care facilities. I was shocked when I saw this report. Janet tells me that she continues to fight for the right of patients' families to place cameras in the rooms of their relatives in nursing homes. Do safety concerns outweigh privacy concerns in the lives of vulnerable people in care? I think they do. Should health care professionals be frightened by this level of transparency and scrutiny? No, I don't think they should. However, cameras are just one tool for transparency and accountability and in our family, we choose to have a personal support network of friends and family who visit often (most times on a daily basis) and on days we don't visit, we telephone. I have a good gut feeling about the trust I have in the current arrangements we have for my mother and for my son. But if I didn't, I would be asking Janet Holden Brumell which brand of camera she recommends. If families want a camera in the room of their elderly parent in care, I believe they should have one.
              Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
              Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

              Comment


                #8
                ((((((Donna))))))

                Why am I not surprised that you were a teacher in your "old life?"

                I agree with you that this incident demonstrates the devaluing of persons with disabling conditions, specifically cognitive. The fact that the teacher was assigned to another classroom, and not even suspended or evaluated, speaks volumes about the attitude of the school and district toward these students. Clearly, they see nothing wrong with her behavior, or they would have taken serious action against her. Again, tragically, Teachers Unions protect bad teachers.

                Now, this teacher has a new group of children to torment and abuse. And the school and district are condoning this abuse by retaining her.

                Where are the other parents of the children in this school? Why aren't they banding together demanding that this teacher is fired?

                When issues arose at my sons' schools, I contacted all of the parents in the program to enlist their support. Together we bombarded the school board, the media, and the district to rectify whatever issue was at hand. This was the covered wagon days, before the internet existed. We had to be vocal and visible to enact the changes needed to protect our children's rights.

                Every battle I fought individually for my children, I fought for their peers and for future generations. Frankly, I do not see that happening these days.

                And, I agree that families should be able to have security cameras in their loved ones' nursing home rooms. The caregivers should have no problem with a camera present, because they are providing excellent care. It's the ones that resist and refuse to allow cameras in the room, who should be looked at with a careful eye.

                To me, all of this begs a larger question: What is wrong with our society that we need security cameras in our nursing facilities and schools to protect our vulnerable children and elders from the people to whom we entrust their care?

                If a society is judged by how well it cares for its most vulnerable members, then, we're failing. Big time.

                I've been fighting for 42 years, and it is not better, it is worse. In every regard, I see the progress we made eroding. All I can do is pray for that to turn around completely through parent advocacy.

                We have to keep fighting.

                Love & Light,

                Rose
                Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                Comment


                  #9
                  ((((((Lisa))))))

                  Your response to Brian's teacher was perfect. I'm happy to hear that he is doing well with his new teacher.

                  Love & Light,

                  Rose
                  Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X