Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Imprisoning Our Children

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Imprisoning Our Children

    ((((((HUGS TO ALL))))))

    The State of Florida has been violating the Olmstead Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act for at least a decade, by warehousing children with disabilities in nursing homes for the elderly. The U.S. Department of Justice is finally intervening, threatening action against the state, if it does not "correct" this practice.

    Children have been ripped from their parents' arms and displaced from their homes, as the State refused to provide medical care or support services for the children, if they were not institutionalized.

    Yes, this is happening right here in the "Land of the Free."

    For details:

    Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...


    Florida has saved millions by cutting programs that support the parents of children with disabilities. The state also refused $40 million in federal dollars that could have been used to provide parental support and encouraged nursing homes to house children with disabilities by increasing the per diem rate, and actually repealed state rules that limit the number of kids that can be housed in nursing homes with adults.

    Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...


    CBS Station WFOR reported earlier this year that the families of more than 250 children were suing Florida for unnecessarily institutionalizing their children, claiming the state told them needed medical care would be withheld unless the children were placed into a nursing care facility.


    Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...

    The United States issued a Findings Letter in September 2012 concluding that Florida is violating the ADA's integration mandate in its provision of services and supports to children with medically complex and medically fragile conditions. After a comprehensive investigation, the Department found that the State of Florida plans, structures, and administers a system of care that has led to the unnecessary institutionalization of children in nursing facilities and places children currently residing in the community at risk of unnecessary institutionalization.


    The fury and outrage coursing through me today, since I heard this story on the news, then began researching it on the internet, is indescribable. The imprisonment of disabled children in Florida is an evil, unconscionable act by the state legislators and governor of Florida. It is an "in-your-face" violation of at least two Federal laws, but I would include a third ~ a violation of IDEA, which ensures that children with special needs receive a "free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive setting."

    For a moment, imagine your child being denied services of any kind, as long as s/he resides with you, and you provide your child's care. You are left with the only option of placing your child in a home for geriatric patients (say, in their 70's to 90's), because without medical care, educational services, therapy, and other supports, your child will not survive. And you do not have the financial resources to provide all of these services to your child (unless you are in the 2% of our population). You are denied access to your child. Your child becomes property of the state.

    Those services the state promised you that your child would receive in the institution do not exist. Your child languishes in a nursing home, and you are not allowed contact with your child.

    What would you do?

    While you file a class action lawsuit, your child remains out of your reach, undoubtedly suffering from neglect. The justice system churns slowly, particularly when one is suing a government entity.

    How did such an abhorrent act of forcibly institutionalizing disabled children happen in this century? In this country? And why has it taken so long for the Federal government to step in? And why is the Federal government allowing Florida to "correct" this abomination, when Federal action should be taken against the State of Florida, and every institutionalized child should be returned to his/her parents? The State of Florida has broken at least 3 Federal Laws! Why the soft-peddling?

    For years, I have been harping on this theme ~ politics is a critical aspect of caring for our children. Absolutely nothing could reinforce that truth more than what has happened to children with disabilities and their parents in Florida. We must keep our ears and eyes open and know what is going on in our state legislatures and in our Congress. We need to align with advocacy organizations, who keep us abreast of law changes and alert us to actions we must take to prevent this despicable, inhumane treatment in Florida from happening to our children or any children anywhere.

    Either we take control, or they do.

    Clearly, things are getting out of hand. Let's take control.

    Love & Light,

    Rose

    Edited to add a note to Mike Weins and the Moderators: I know this is a political issue, and politics are not permitted for discussion on Braintalk. Sometimes politics cannot be separated from the major issues surrounding us, and I believe that this is a perfect example of that circumstance.

    As parents of children with special needs, we must be aware of everything political affecting the rights and welfare of our children. We cannot parse out politics from the services our children receive, as provided by Federal and State laws.

    We devote our lives to providing for and protecting our children, and a large part of our responsibility is ensuring their civil rights. The civil and human rights of children with disabilities in Florida have been severely violated. We need to be aware that this is happening, so that we can prevent it from ever occurring again.

    Thank you for your understanding. I hope you will allow this thread to remain.
    Last edited by Earth Mother 2 Angels; 01-09-2013, 08:02 PM.
    Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

    #2
    I watched this news report yesterday as well and as I looked at Tyler the tears flowed. I have a friend who had a child with OS in Florida. She died at three because of the lack of caring by that state due to her extreme handicaps. I remember her moms constant attempts to get what Carly needed to survive and how many roadblocks she hit because of insurance problems, lack of programs to help her, uncaring doctors and hospital screw ups. An attitude of "with the severity of Carly's deficits, why try so hard to keep her alive". She was treated more like an animal to put down than an ill child in need of help. It hurt then, it hurts now. This country is in dire need of a healthy dose of kindness, compassion, caring and hope and Florida would be a good place to start. It is a state I would never live in.
    grandmother of Tyler (27): Ohtahara Syndrome/SCN2a gene mutation, cortically visually impaired, quadriplegic, severely developmentally delayed, no speech, severe intractable seizures, frontal and temporal lobe atrophy, progressive scoliosis/kyphosis, chronic kidney stones & UTI's, gastroparesis, 100% tube fed, autonomic dysreflexia, but what a precious gift from God. "Lord, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change."

    Comment


      #3
      Dear Rose,
      I am horrified by the warehousing of children and young adults with disabilities in nursing home for the elderly in Florida. It's a story that I have been following for a while. But Florida is not alone. Every single western country that I know of, including my own country of Canada has practices like this. Currently, in Ontario, there is a major province-wide investigation by the Ombudsman into the dreadful lack of services for adults with disabilities and their families. There will be a class action suit against the provincial government, I am sure.
      This is not partisan politics. This is about a demographic shift in our world - one in which an ageing population is now pitted against children and adults with disabilities for diminishing health and social care resources. Add to that, a consumer driven society that devalues our children because they will never be employable. Therefore they are expendable because they do not have human worth. This is a discussion that we must have in every online forum that we can. We must speak up to defend the value and the contribution of our children and our families. Florida is one example of what has become a pandemic of indifference to those with care needs. This is absolutely an appropriate topic for Braintalk Communities and I would love to hear others' thoughts, concerns and also their experiences in successful advocacy for sharing care where everyone is happy, healthy, and valued.
      Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
      Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

      Comment


        #4
        That is scary!! I think people just don't care/think about it until they personally have to go thru it themselves. In fact, right now I haven't talked to my best friend in well over a month due to differences in opinion over politics--medical insurance issues (I am in favor of universal healthcare, she is very much not). It really bothers me. But then I wonder, well probably lots of people feel that way who don't deal with the things we do as caregivers. I had no idea of what the state of Florida is doing, heard/saw nothing in the news about it....sad that something so horrible is not on the front page! In Wisconsin here, when all the budget stuff with the governor went down, it was all over our news....he had froze FamilyCare which provided funds to have people cared for at home which would force people to put loved ones in nursing homes to get care. It ended up that the federal gov't forced the state to open family care back up, something with the Medicare/medicaid rules that they could not freeze it....I never read the exact details but did follow the story. It's so hard to be an activist when busy just dealing with the medical issues going on in my own house. It sucks how services can vary so much from state to state. <sigh>

        Lisa O.
        sigpicLisa O: mom to Caitlin (14-CP, VA shunt, seizures), Brandon (12), Tyler (10), Logan (7)...my babies are all getting so old!!

        Comment


          #5
          I have several times over the years heard anecdotes on a similar vein wherein parents give up custody of their child to the state so that the state can support the child. I'm not sure how often that in fact happens, or if it is influenced by certain state laws.....
          Momster, mom to 2 boys: one of whom has CP, NLD, ADD, anxiety disorder, osteopenia/porosis and a few other letters following his name; and married 25 years to a wonderful guy

          Comment


            #6
            ((((((Tamie, Donna, Lisa, & Momster))))))

            The overwhelming theme with regard to providing services for our children is, "Why bother?" Devaluation, as you've all addressed, is the crux of that theme.

            In the 1980's, our State Superintendent of Schools publicly said that special education was a waste of taxpayers' money, because "there is no return on that investment."

            When programs for our children are the first ones on the budget cutting block, that attitude of devaluation is most evident. Our children are not viewed as contributing meaningfully to society, rather as a drain on the coffers of government budgets. In our state, children with special needs are used as bargaining chips in budget negotiations.

            It takes the hue and cry of parents, advocates, and those elected officials, who have some compassion, to shine a bright light on this discrimination, and to prevent those budget cuts to our children's programs and services.

            States receiving Federal money are required to follow Federal law in the administration of those funds. Federal law supersedes state law in most cases. In Florida, the state has violated, by my count, at least 3 Federal laws. The only reason why Florida refused the $40 million from the Federal government to assist these children was to circumvent Federal law pertaining to the administration of the funds.

            The purpose of the Federal laws, such as Olmstead, ADA, and IDEA, is to protect the civil and human rights of children and adults with disabilities. So, whether Florida took Federal funds or refused them, they have still violated Federal law(s). They must be held accountable.

            * * * * * * * * * * * *

            Lisa, it is difficult to be an activist, when you are coping with the daily needs of your children, and you are so right that we often do not become involved until an issue affects us directly. But, with the changing nature of the economy and politics, we need to be aware of issues that may affect us eventually. Your state saw the light, but what if it hadn't?

            And, as Donna and I have said a few times, it's never too early to begin learning about options for your child's adulthood. What programs, services, living options, and supports are out there, and where do they need improvement, so that when your child needs those services, they are in place? It is too much to take on, but it is a necessary part of our planning for our children's future.

            Donna, yes, our voices are vital in opening the hearts and minds of others, who do not comprehend the worth and value of our children. When people only attach worth and value to earning capacity, that task is extremely difficult.

            And it is a global problem, but thankfully, as far as I know, this is not a widespread problem in the U.S. We have laws in place to prevent this kind of discrimination, which makes Florida's actions even more disgusting.

            Tamie, it's heart breaking that Carly's needs were neglected so completely, and all of these years later, nothing has changed. I agree with you about Florida.

            Momster, some parents may surrender custody of their children to the state for a variety of reasons. I know that our institutions were overflowing for many years, before Olmstead was passed, primarily because many parents were encouraged by physicians and state counselors to give up their children and "live your own life." Warehousing was more convenient and easier, not necessarily more cost effective, and the matter of separating children from their parents and families was not considered. We were told we'd be "better off" without our children.

            It appears that parents in Florida were coerced into giving up their children, as the state was denying those children services, if the parents retained care and custody of their children. This is intolerable.

            * * * * * * * * * * * *

            Our children are not disposable and expendable. They are not political pawns. They have human and civil rights. They did not choose to have their disabilities. They didn't create our economic crisis, and they should never be sacrificed on the altar of special interest politics.

            Nursing homes have a powerful lobby, and any trend toward home care jeopardizes their hefty profits. Out of home care is 3 to 5 times more costly than in home care, depending upon the locality. So, why would any government entity choose institutionalization over in home or in community care?

            Follow the money trail, which goes from the lobby into the pockets of the legislators.

            * * * * * * * * * * * *

            In the 1990's, I joined other advocates in a battle against a large nursing home corporation attempting to privatize our IHSS program. We prevailed by proving that they were seeking profits by denying qualified recipients in home services, forcing them out of their homes into nursing facilities. We shamed the elected officials, whose campaign funds were well oiled by this corporation. And we threatened lawsuits for violation of Federal guidelines for the IHSS program.

            We hired babysitters for our children, and we turned out en masse at meetings with the corporate shills and county supervisors and agency representatives. Several times those meetings were cancelled, without notice, or moved to a different location, so we'd arrive and find no one there to speak to us. Someone would track down the new location, and we'd pile in our cars to drive there, just to find that they had left.

            We brought the media into our fight. That helped greatly. No cell phones and no internet then. This was all a grassroots effort, networking by home/land phone and fliers in the snail mail.

            * * * * * * * * * * * *

            If we want to change the world for our children, we have to go the extra mile, put ourselves out there, speak up, and fight for their rights.

            Every time I wrote to a newspaper about an issue, or my boys and I were featured, with photographs, in a large newspaper, or a local network TV news channel interviewed us, or I stood and spoke before greedy representatives of a multi-million dollar corporation or the school board or elected officials or a hearing judge, I feared that I was exploiting my children. But what I feared more is what would happen to my children and their peers, if I didn't do it.

            How often do you hear a politician or an elected official at any level of government mention the needs of people with disabilities, of children with special needs? Minorities, women, LGBT and others are included in speeches, either positively or negatively, but people with disabling conditions are ignored altogether. Until legislation starts wending its way through the channels, and advocates get wind of it and put pressure on the politicians/legislators, people with disabilities, especially our children, are the Forgotten Minority.

            It's too easy to shun them, to use them for political points, to barter with their lives, to balance the failing economy on their backs.

            And it has been this way for far too long. I can testify that it's been this way for 43 years, at least. We need substantial change. And that begins with how people with disabilities, including our children, are perceived by those we elect and those who elect them.

            It is up to us to make that change.

            * * * * * * * * * * * *

            NOTE: Obviously, it has taken me some time to compose this post! I have started and stopped, edited, and added, deleted, then added, because there is so much in my heart to be said about this subject. Sometimes, I am overwhelmed with sadness to realize that all of our efforts, mine and other parents, have not resulted in the changes we sought, so that you don't have to fight for your children's needs and rights. And it angers me. What has happened in Florida infuriates me. This should not be happening in 2013.

            Use all of the resources available to you now, especially social media, to continue fighting for the Forgotten Minority. Find an advocacy group and join it. Get updates on issues of importance to your children via email from advocacy organizations. Write to your legislators. Comment on articles on the internet about issues relevant to our children. Let your voice be heard, let your experience and knowledge be guideposts to change.

            Love & Light,

            Rose
            Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

            Comment


              #7
              Thank you for this, Rose. I will add my voice wherever and whenever I can. We have a provincial enquiry right now in Ontario into the dreadful lack of resources for adults with developmental disabilities here. Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...
              Recently, I received an email from a young woman in her 20s from another Canadian province whose needs could not be met home so she was placed in a nursing home. She is desperate to get out. At least she is not a child though! But still, it's terribly wrong and should never be allowed. Every other resident of this young woman's current home is over the age of 80. I will raise my voice and hopefully, each drop of water (so to speak) will combine to make a tsunami. xoDonna
              Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
              Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

              Comment


                #8
                All I can say is... Wow.
                sigpicMommy to Jimmie, diagnosed with Infantile Spasms at 4 1/2 months and LGS at 20 months, and Charlie, so far healthy and happy.

                Comment


                  #9
                  just want to thank all of you for letting us be informed. the title of this post might benefit from a change? I've ignored it until just now.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Any ideas for an alternate post title? Thanks for chiming in to this vital conversation.
                    Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
                    Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

                    Comment


                      #11
                      ((((((Donna, Lacy, & Buttons 2))))))

                      Donna ~ Thank you for providing the link to the Ontario Ombudsman's investigation. The focus of that investigation, according to the article, is "whether the Ministry is adequately responding to urgent situations involving adults with developmental disabilities, and whether it is doing enough to co-ordinate, monitor and facilitate access to services for them." Hmmm ... I think we already know the answer to those two questions: NO!

                      All of the foot-dragging by bureaucracies on the mistreatment and institutionalization of children/adults with DD is obscene!

                      Wouldn't you like to know how that $472 million, intended to provide services for persons with DD, is being spent?! Seems like the nursing facilities are raking in the cash.

                      While your Ombudsman studies the problem, and our DOJ sends vaguely threatening letters to states violating Federal laws, the children and adults are SUFFERING. Their parents and families are SUFFERING.

                      I'm running out of words to describe how angry I am about all of this.

                      Lacy ~ It's pretty startling, isn't it? I keep reminding myself that we don't live in a third world country or under a dictatorship.

                      Buttons ~ Perhaps you could explain why this thread's title prompted you to ignore the thread? The title was my first choice, and then I mulled over other possible titles, but kept returning to this title, because it accurately summarizes the content of the thread. Children with disabilities, especially children with developmental disabilities, are being dumped in elderly nursing homes, neglected, and deprived of their rights. To me, that is tantamount to imprisonment.

                      Although I am unable to edit my post or title now (too much time has elapsed since the original posting), I am truly interested in your reaction to the thread title and your suggestions for a better one.

                      ((((((Mike Weins & Moderator 7))))))

                      Thank you for your "Thanks" and for allowing this thread to remain so that we can discuss this crisis. I am very grateful.

                      Love & Light,

                      Rose
                      Last edited by Earth Mother 2 Angels; 01-20-2013, 06:44 PM.
                      Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Rose and other interested parents - have a read of my new blog post with a theory of why this is happening to our society - Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register...
                        Let me know what you think. Have we jettisoned our values? Are WE the threat to the rest of society?
                        Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
                        Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

                        Comment


                          #13
                          O.o WOW! Once again a complete disregard for the lives of the disabled. This stuff makes me angry. Unbelievable. And it's all because they can't do what able bodied or less disabled people can do. No respect for their lives whatsoever.
                          Mild Spastic Diplegia Cerebral Palsy and bad proprioception.
                          My website for my original short films! http://cripvideoproductions.com/astrokeofendurance.php

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Rose, you wrote "nursing homes are a powerful lobby" - I feel strongly that we need to ally with the seniors movement and with the nursing homes lobby to keep our children OUT of nursing homes. It is not good for the elderly to have sick infants or children with disabilities in their midst. Nursing homes are meant to be communities - the kinds of recreational and therapeutic programming that are designed for adults are absolutely inappropriate for children. Surely the nursing home lobby would support NOT having children in their homes. And what about a child's right to an education? I read all the links about how Florida is 'defending' this awful practice and I didn't read anything about how they get around that issue.
                            Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
                            Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Children forced into Nursing Homes? just a thought. old ladies such as myself have no clue this is going on. it's criminal for sure!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X