Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

CN Central: JUNE UPDATES!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    Rose thanks again for the eye opener. All of what you said certainly needs to be said about this topic. Your life experiences certainly make you a good judge of dealing with the misconceptions of life with and as a disabled person. I would hate to see these ideas go backwards also. If nothing else the movie has opened up a conversation which hopefully will be heard. I'm not sorry I saw it but I have had to search my brain for why I didn't see the ramifications of the way the topic was handled. I guess I got sucked into the emotions of it and not how it would effect other lives. As I said before I don't give movies the power(that I probably should) to make dramatic changes. I came a away mostly thinking what a good life he could have had he really needed help to see it and maybe he wouldn't have ended it.
    Mary Grace

    Comment


      #17
      Rose, I don’t remember the number. Just slightly higher and now it is normal. What in the diet might cause that? As far as I know the test my relative took for neurons was easy though I have no idea what they do to treat it.

      To everyone: Thank you for your thoughts on “Me Before You”! I love hearing all of your different perspectives!

      If we tried to make every movie "politically correct" nothing would ever be made.
      This sentence right here is why I make my films! However movie makers still have a certain amount of responsibility in what they present to the public and I take this responsibility very very seriously.

      Imagine for a moment you are a teenager with some kind of disability.
      You, like most teenagers, are insecure in yourself. You just want to fit in.
      At school, you feel like an outcast. You can't go to many parties because the venues aren't accessible. Sometimes the others call you names. You missed out on a class trip recently because it was "too hard" to accommodate you. The teachers don't have the same expectations for your career prospects. You are not expected to go to university or indeed have a career.
      At home you rely on family members to help you with basic things your siblings were doing years ago. You hate it.
      Me Before You comes out. You've heard it's a romance and you like the look of the guy. He's disabled, like you.
      You see it. In the end, he kills himself because he'd rather be dead than disabled. People around you are dabbing their eyes as they exit the cinema. You catch one of them looking at you. "I'm so sorry," she says "It must be so hard." "I'd hate to be like that," you hear others say. They stop and stare when they see you.
      At school, people have seen it too. You hear them talk about it and sometimes hear your name mentioned. One day, you're heading back to class at the end of a break and you pass a group of classmates.
      "Hey," one of them says, "You seen that movie with the disabled person in it?" "Yeah," you say, hoping to be invited next time they see a movie. "Maybe you should do what that guy does and kill yourself. Better for everyone eh?" The words ring in your ears.
      "Maybe" you think. Like many teenagers, you've thought about it before.
      On particularly hard days, you think about the movie and what people at the cinema and at school have said. You're a burden. You're worthless. You're better off dead.
      One day, you go into the bathroom, take out your dad's pills and....
      Me Before You may be "just a movie" but its messages are extremely damaging and could have very real consequences. Shame on Hollywood. They should be doing so much better than this.
      I read a digital version of the book after seeing the movie trailer and I have to agree with every word CPchick wrote as well as what you wrote Rose. Starvation is a cruel and painful death. No one should have to ever experience that! I actually thought of Jon and had the same gut reaction of “This is SO WRONG!” while reading the book because I know how much Jon’s life has value and I don’t want the system to kill off Jon or people like him! On my film blog I got a response from a teenager who is newly diabetic,she felt depressed because she felt like a burden to her family, and she said my films helped her because she saw that her life could still be vibrant and full with diabetes. If she had seen “Me Before You” instead she might have given up on life. Then I think of my teacher with the stroke. When I saw him have his dizzy spells I was so afraid he was “suffering”. Here’s the thing: HE WASN’T. He knew how to handle it and with enough time his body and mind have adjusted to the physical effects of the stroke. He knew he was fine. He said "Sometimes I don't feel well but I was only minutes away from dying and I would much rather be disabled than dead. I just didn't want to die. I didn't want my children to be without their father." *It was not my place to decide whether he was suffering or not. Just like it is not a doctors place to decide whether our lives are worth it. I realize that able bodied people who become disabled people must go through a physical and mental adjustment to being disabled and depression is a perfectly natural part of this change for some people. Disability for many is often connected to something traumatic like a near fatal accident or illness. Nobody goes around thinking “I want to be disabled when I grow up”. Disability is hard. Acting like it isn’t hard is a lie. Disabled people can be depressed over things that have nothing to do with being disabled too such as the death of a child. So I have no problem with this movie depicting a depressed character. My major problem with this movie is the use of ASSISTED SUICIDE. I hate the way the subject was handled in “Me Before You”! I have always been against suicide and assisted suicide. I can understand why someone may want to commit suicide but suicide is never the answer. I have seen what suicide does to the people who loved the person who committed suicide after the death has occurred(members of my own family committed suicide before I was born and my family is still dealing with the emotional consequences now). When someone dies in a suicide a piece of all of their friends and family die along with them. One life effects the lives of so many others. Assisted suicide based on disability makes it seem like disability is a fate worse than death which could not be further from the truth. So I can NOT support the movie in theaters.

      I respect ALL of your opinions of course! I’m not trying to start any political battles here. Just discussing. No offense to anyone!
      Mild Spastic Diplegia Cerebral Palsy and bad proprioception.
      My website for my original short films! http://cripvideoproductions.com/astrokeofendurance.php

      Comment


        #18
        (((((((Mary Grace)))))) ~

        Our experiences form our reactions and opinions toward everything. Your experience with Kathleen has been one of involvement, inclusion, a community embracing her and loving her. Has any professional ever told you to give up on Kathleen? I pray not, and I don't recall you ever mentioning such a comment. Perhaps that is why you didn't see the potential negative impact of the film's statement.

        And, as I said, I've had nearly 50 years on the front lines. It's difficult for some to imagine what the attitude was toward children with disabilities 50 years ago. What life was like before we had IDEA, the ADA. When doctors were baffled and didn't know what to do with a child who had severe disabilities.

        As late as the 1980s, our state Superintendent of Schools publicly stated that educating special needs children was a waste of tax payer dollars, because those children will never become working, tax paying adults. He said, "They will always be a drain on our budgets throughout their lifetimes."

        We had to fight to pass all of the laws to protect our children's civil rights, including the Olmstead act, which closed down numerous institutions, and placed individuals with developmental disabilities in community-based residential settings.

        In our garage, we have boxes filled with reams of letters I wrote to elected officials.

        And I'm still fighting. Now, Jon is a middle aged man, classified by his physician as Palliative Care, and I still can't get a PT out here to address his lymphedema, and his last visit with his nurse was unauthorized. It's getting worse. He should be receiving everything he needs to be comfortable and safe in his own home, but the System figures he's on his way out, so maybe denying him services and supplies will speed up the process and save them money.

        Because of my experience, I can see the potential danger of a film like Me Before You in perpetuating the myth, among a general population unfamiliar with disabilities, that people with disabilities are miserable, bitter, feel like they are a burden, and want to die.

        I grew up during a time, when TV shows with characters in wheelchairs were typically presented as angry, cranky, and annoying. With the exception of Ironsides, I suppose. But in the 1940s, the movie series, Dr. Kildare, had the grouchiest old geezer in a wheelchair full of disdain and bitterness.

        These are stereotypes we need to erase.

        And, when a political candidate can ridicule a reporter with disabilities, that's a Red Flag that too many people in our country/society still regard people with disabilities as worthless, disposable, embarrassing, foolish, scary ... the list is long as to what this conjures in the minds of people.

        We're not in a safe place as a community. We still have thousands of miles to go to reach a destination of acceptance and equality for people with disabilities. So we need to be vigilant about any negative messages being spread far and wide for public consumption.

        And while you may not take movies seriously or are affected on a deeper level by them, others are. Film is a powerful form of persuasion. That's not a criticism of you, Mary Grace. I love you for your innocence inspired by Kathleen's positive impact on those in your circle. But others, who don't have your experience, or who have no experience with people who have disabilities, will have a different take away from this film.

        I just pray that you know that I truly appreciate where you are coming from in this discussion and that I completely respect your opinion, thoughts and viewpoint.



        Love & Light,

        Rose
        Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

        Comment


          #19
          ((((((funnylegs4)))))) ~

          I have a feeling that we're all on the same page on the issues raised by MBY. And we all love and respect each other, so we're freely communicating our thoughts and opinions, without judgment of each other.

          I'm so very sorry that your family suffered losses from suicide. I've known several grieving parents, whose children died by suicide, and I know from them the torment, the guilt, the "what could I have done to prevent this?", and the anguish they experience for the rest of their lives. Tragically, their children were severely mentally ill and did feel that their lives were worthless. One young woman was addicted to meth, which drove her to suicide. Their stories are all different, but their decisions were the same.

          And when we say that suicide is not the answer, it may be because we're not at risk, or we've never been to that dark place beckoning for release. If we haven't been there, we can't fully comprehend that compulsion.

          So, I want to be very careful that I do not condemn or vilify anyone, who chooses suicide.

          That makes it complicated when discussing MBY, since that is the ultimate choice of the main character. My objection to the film is principally on how the general public will respond to it, i.e., equating disability to a fate worse than death. This is a commonly held viewpoint by the general population, and I do not want it to be reinforced by this film, which may romanticize and glamorize the character's suicide.

          Another objection I have with MBY, as I do with many other films featuring people with disabilities, is the casting of able-bodied actors to portray a person with a disability.

          So, funnylegs4, here's where you receive a standing ovation:



          It's time for more positive messages, images, role models; more uplifting stories; more true heroes. In fact, it is long overdo.

          American Sniper grossed millions and was nominated for Academy Awards. Where is the Academy Award winning film about a wounded warrior, who battles his way back to a full life? Starring a wounded warrior in the lead role? Where is that movie?

          I want to see movies about you, about Erin, about Kathleen, Tyler, Nick, Caitlin, my sons, and all of our courageous CN children and their parents. Overcoming the obstacles and odds against them time after time after time.

          I want the world to see the other side of disabilities, where hope lives and possibilities are waiting, where love and community work together for positive outcomes.

          The world that we see.

          Thank you, funnylegs4, for doing just that.

          Love & Light,

          Rose
          Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

          Comment


            #20
            Just to put my 2 cents worth in here. Personally I hate movies like this. Generally written by someone who has no clue and acted by perfectly healthy and usually young, beautiful people who will get up from their fake wheelchairs, move on after the movie scene is done and never give it another thought. As a family living with a severely disabled young adult who fights every day to LIVE regardless of what he lacks; what he is unable to do; places he is unable to go; activities he is unable to participate in; loved ones he will never be able to verbally connect with; every day existence that is a struggle, daily pain and relentless seizures; total dependence on others for everything, and yet he fights back. He wants to be here. Why? I have no idea. He LOVES life or he would simply give up and go. He is not a pound puppy that we can simply eliminate because it is too hard for him or for us to carry on. That is not an option. What is an option is to be sure his quality of life is the best we can give him. Daily telling him he is loved, cherished and accepted by voice and by touch. He speaks volumns every day without ever saying a single word. He teaches profound lessons to all who have a heart to hear. He is real and lives in a real world and will continue to do so until that day that the Lord calls him home. His is a story of courage, endurance and grace.
            grandmother of Tyler (27): Ohtahara Syndrome/SCN2a gene mutation, cortically visually impaired, quadriplegic, severely developmentally delayed, no speech, severe intractable seizures, frontal and temporal lobe atrophy, progressive scoliosis/kyphosis, chronic kidney stones & UTI's, gastroparesis, 100% tube fed, autonomic dysreflexia, but what a precious gift from God. "Lord, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change."

            Comment


              #21
              Oh Rose! THANK YOU SO SO SO MUCH!!! Your compliments made my day! I’m so touched! When I get messages like your post I know I have done something right! Your words motivate me to continue making more films! I hope to write your beautiful stories for all to see. I don’t mind some characters being bitter or having bad attitudes if it is done correctly i.e realistically and while making it clear that the bitter ones are not the majority. I hate stereotypes because I have been stereotyped. I agree. A major reason I cast disabled actors is it comes across in a much more honest way because these actors live the experience they are playing out on screen. On my blog there is an interview I did where I talked about this in a bit more detail. Here’s the link Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register... I also get to give disabled people work and something they can put on their resumes so future employers may be more interested in hiring them. Interestingly the movie “Best Years of Our Lives”(I think that’s the title) which was released in 1946, had a real life disabled wounded worrier in it so I don’t understand why they don’t do that in movies now with the talk of inclusion everywhere in 2016. I would love to work with wounded worriers if I had the chance. It would be my honor.
              Of course I would never, ever, ever condemn someone for committing suicide! I have the exact same problem with the movie that you do. It makes disability seem terrible. I don’t like that Jon’s doc classified him as Palliative because that means they think he is already dying which is awful.

              Like you, Mary Grace I was accepted for most of my life so it wasn’t until I met older disabled people who were born way before the ADA did I start to become aware. So I understand where your perspectives come from. I use to be the exact same way. I had to realize the opportunity I have now was hard fought. Thank you to Rose for fighting for these rights!

              Amen to that Tamie! Especially the part about Tyler not being a puppy! Thanks so much! Tyler is loved and wanted!
              Mild Spastic Diplegia Cerebral Palsy and bad proprioception.
              My website for my original short films! http://cripvideoproductions.com/astrokeofendurance.php

              Comment


                #22
                ((((((Tamie)))))) ~

                AMEN!

                Not having seen MBY nor read the book, I'm guessing that the story doesn't include the main character's struggle with obtaining health care, or services and supplies. He could afford to hire a private caregiver (and a financial assistant? or an assistant who handled his financial/legal affairs?). He could also afford to fly to another country, where assisted suicide was legal.

                This is where there is a significant cognitive dissonance between MBY and reality.

                We live in a culture/society, where "heroes" are athletes, rock stars, actors/actresses, race car drivers, etc. So, anything less than perfect is looked upon with disdain. That is why the general public might view MBY with the "better dead than disabled" concept already embedded in their thought processes.

                We need honest films about disabilities, about REAL HEROES, with actors/actresses, who have disabilities. We need to make movies revealing how difficult it is for people with disabilities to receive the care and services they need, and how they are constantly fighting The System, and disinterested physicians, who just throw up their hands and scratch their heads.

                Too many people think that persons with disabilities are living off the dole. No distinction is made between those, who can, and those who cannot, work. They refer to programs like IHSS and Regional Center as "welfare."

                There is tremendous ignorance among the general population about people with disabilities, because people with disabilities are the Forgotten Minority. The last to be mentioned in a string of minorities, if at all. The last to receive services, the first to receive budget cuts to those services. Sometimes, they are the least able to fight for themselves. Like Jon and Michael, and Tyler, and Kathleen.

                We need to see books and movies about these realities to wake up the able-bodied public, who thinks that people with disabilities are miserable and want to be dead. In thinking this way, it justifies their distaste for paying taxes to support the services and programs for people with disabilities.

                If I had time, I would write at least one book about my boys. And then a dozen other books about all of the children and parents I've met on my journey with my boys. But, alas and alack, I don't have time, and I'm getting older by the second.

                Meanwhile ... Back to Updates ~

                Tamie ~ how is Tyler? Are you getting positive results with the indwelling catheter?

                And everyone else ~ please check in with your updates ~

                Love & Light,

                Rose
                Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                Comment


                  #23
                  Hi Everyone!
                  Sorry I'm late to this update thread. I'm quite busy recently - selling our house and moving to the country but still close to Nick, travelling abroad later today, writing a new book, etc. Life is good :) I have been worried about this film MBY - like others, I was very concerned about the message it sends relating to the value of a life of someone with disabilities. I've been posting online articles about this film on facebook - it's a dangerous precedent for pwd. for sure. I'm part of this initiative in Canada Only registered and activated users can see links., Click Here To Register.... The fact is, most Canadians do not have access to palliative care and not to mention appropriate home supports for disability and illness. So 'suffering' can often be a result of lack of support and a reasonable choice becomes assisting suicide. This is wrong. Why oh why isn't there proper depiction of people with disabilities getting on with their lives in film? We need more of THAT! It's lovely to hear your voices again here at CN - I promise to drop in more often! xo
                  Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
                  Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

                  Comment


                    #24
                    ((((((funnylegs4)))))) ~

                    I hope that you understand how important the work you are doing is, how it is impacting the lives of so many people with disabilities, and helping to destroy the stereotypes, which we all loathe. Your work is truly important, and I support you 100% all the way in your endeavors.

                    Everything I did these past 46 years for my children, I also did for you, and for all of the children here on CN and around our country. What I learned from fighting for my boys allowed me to teach other parents how to advocate for their children.

                    I was an organizer. I spoke in front of school boards, rallies, administrative law judges, school officials, and every state and local agency knew my name, every governor, every county supervisor, every executive director of every agency knew who I was. I was interviewed by major newspapers and local TV news. My boys were at the forefront of the movement. I worried that I might be exploiting them, until I realized that this was their fight, and they are soldiers carrying the banner for civil rights.

                    I linked arms with many other parents, and we waged the battle. We fought so that today's parents wouldn't have to fight. And yet, here we are, and today's parents have to fight just as hard and long as we did.

                    I would love to write the script for that movie. It would tell the history of how exhausted, frustrated parents battered our legislators to pass the laws in place now. We would not be denied.

                    It takes determination to fight discrimination.

                    So, you keep doing your important work, funnylegs4, and you make your mark in the world. I have complete faith in you that you will succeed.

                    Love & Light,

                    Rose
                    Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                    Comment


                      #25
                      ((((((Donna)))))) ~

                      Thank you for taking time out of your extremely busy schedule to stop by and share your thoughts. I wish that I could read your Facebook posts, as I'm certain you share great insight on the MBY topic.

                      I'm so surprised that Canada doesn't offer Palliative Care and home care. I'm so glad that you are part of the VPS initiative. Perhaps with your new Prime Minister, things will change and catch up to the 21st century?

                      Praying that your home sells quickly, for health for you and your family, and for safe travels.

                      Love & Light,

                      Rose
                      Mom to Jon, 49, & Michael, 32, born with an undiagnosed progressive neuromuscular disease. Angel Michael received his wings in 2003. Angel Jon received his wings in 2019. In 2020, Jim, their Dad, joined them.

                      Comment


                        #26
                        Hi again everyone! Funnylegs, check this out: With so much news generated by ME BEFORE YOU and other important disability events and issues, here is an opportunity for budding journalists with disabilities to apply for the 2nd Annual CBS News/Lights! Camera! Access! 2.0 Internship for college students with disabilities with CBS News in NYC. Applications due Tuesday, June 14- Thanks CUNY for coordinating.

                        CUNY LEADS - Central Office of Student Affairs (COSA) - CUNY
                        CUNY LEADS.
                        CUNY.EDU|BY THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
                        Rose, we have palliative care and home supports, just not enough and it's patchy geographically. It's not a right, but assisting dying is. sigh. xo
                        Donna, Mum to Natalie (22), ablebodied, kind and beautiful and Nicholas(26), severe CP, non-verbal, tube fed, multiple surgeries, chronic pain, happy kid except when the Liverpool football club or the Ottawa Senators Hockey Team are losing!
                        Check out my blog: http://www.donnathomson.com

                        Comment


                          #27
                          There was a protest about Me Before You in my city last night. I didn't go, partly cos I have to be a bit careful working in the public service and getting involved in such things. But local media reported on it which was good. There are protests going on in Australia at the moment too. I feel such a movement is long overdue, so maybe we can thank the movie for something.

                          Exciting happenings this week. The annual conference on the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities is at the UN in New York this week. Some of my colleagues are there. This year is particularly exciting because elections were held for the CRPD Committee - the international monitoring body that oversees implementation of the convention - and NZ had a nominee, who got elected! First person with a learning disability on any UN Committee anywhere in the world. With NZ's former PM running for Secretary General, I am a very proud Kiwi.
                          And excited.... hoping to get to go to the conference next year. Watch out USA!
                          Enjoying the excitements of life. Looking forward to what's to come! What a ride!

                          Comment


                            #28
                            Donna, thank you so much! I saw that Internship info through a listserv I receive via email. I thought about it for sure! I don’t consider myself a journalist personally at this point in my life. I’m simply a creator. It’s really awful that things are so patchy in your country and it does disturb me in a number of ways that assisting dying is a right. Thank you for being part of that initiative! I agree that “Me Before You” is dangerous. I recently saw a thread on a video site where a person was talking about “Me Before You” and the commenter said quote
                            “If I ended up like Will, I would want to be put to death immediately too because I wouldn’t be worth crap like that. And if my wife were paralyzed I would put her to death as a act of true love,”
                            I was like WOW! I felt so heartbroken that the commenter thought he would be worthless as a disabled person. And would even want his wife killed in assisted suicide. That type of mentality needs to be ended IMMEDIATELY!

                            CPchick, I’m thrilled that there are protests going on! The UN news is certainly exciting!

                            Rose, thank you ever so much! I feel so honored that you think my work is so vitally important!! What you wrote to Tamie is exactly what I’m trying to do, show disability as part of regular life,show disabled people working,being loved, show disabled actors and disabled bodies as beautiful! Many times in my life I have had people assume I am on SSD or SSI etc. I would never condemn or judge those who need these programs but I’m highly insulted by the assumption that I can not work at all. I work and I enjoy it. My teacher with the stroke works, the people in my films work. The disabled people I know who are gainfully employed are highly driven and motivated. They always go 80 miles per hour and never let anything stop them. I'v even heard of people who are almost completely paralyzed working. I know unemployement is higher for the disabled and if more people realized we wanted to work this would change and then disabled people would have more money and therefore more resources available to them. I think it is great you were such a huge activist! Have you ever seen the movie “The Brooke Ellison Story”? It’s a true story and while unfortunately the disabled character is played by an able bodied actress, it does show a good amount of the struggle for Brooke to return to her community with proper care needs and accessibility after being hit by a car and how doctors and school boards originally set almost no expectations for her. I wouldn’t say we are completely a forgotten minority anymore but there is a lot of work ahead. We are almost never mentioned in political campaigns. You really should write a book, even if you just write 2 sentences per month or something like that you would end up with a book in no time! Try at least, if nothing else! That’s how I ended up writing films!

                            On a separate totally unrelated note, somebody who has dizzy spells like my teacher used to told me the eye movement he had during his dizzy spells is called “Saccades” It was such a relief to finally have a name for that weird almost seizure like thing his eyes used to do. Her description was exactly what I saw happen to him back in December.
                            I also should be around more now because my schedule has lightened up.
                            Last edited by funnylegs4; 06-16-2016, 09:49 PM.
                            Mild Spastic Diplegia Cerebral Palsy and bad proprioception.
                            My website for my original short films! http://cripvideoproductions.com/astrokeofendurance.php

                            Comment


                              #29
                              In regards to my posts about Me Before You: I finally got to see*“Finding Dory” all the way through and it is a GREAT way to represent disability. Dory is very obviously disabled and the film shows that disability comes with BOTH struggles and joys and the message is*“There is always another way to do something” which has been my motto for CP all my life! Finally the media gets it right! Finding Dory is the COMPLETE OPPOSITE OF Me Before You and does everything right that Me Before You got horribly wrong! Finding Dory has 3 disabled characters in it! Finding Dory is just as touching and well animated as the original Finding Nemo! Nemo is even cuter in this movie! WATCH IT!*
                              Mild Spastic Diplegia Cerebral Palsy and bad proprioception.
                              My website for my original short films! http://cripvideoproductions.com/astrokeofendurance.php

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X